Aulby is the only bowler to win three USBC Masters titles (1989, 1995, 1998) and owns 29 PBA Tour titles. Among his PBA titles are two PBA National Championships, one U.S. Open, one Tournament of Champions and one Touring Players Championship. In addition to his other PBA titles, he has 75 other top five finishes including second, third and fourth places in both the Tournament of Champions and PBA National Championship. With more than $2 million in PBA career earnings, Aulby is a four-time Bowler of the Year, two-time Steve Nagy Sportsmanship award winner and George Young High Average Award winner in 1995. He was the first player to win PBA Rookie of the Year and PBA Player of the year honors.