NAIA All-America Teams
| 2022-2023 Women | 2022-2023 Men | |
| First Team All-American Caitlin Lucas, Baker (POY) Bailey Delrose, St. Francis-Ill. Lindsay Brown, Tennessee Southern Brianna Rogers, Pikeville Kristina Catoe, Pikeville |
First Team All-American Bryce Oliver, Pikeville (POY) Alex Acosta, Saint Xavier Hayden Stippich, Tennessee Southern Julian Salinas, SCAD-Savannah Dylan Mollo, Marian-Ind. |
|
| Second Team All-American Emily Cheesman, Milligan Jordan Czerw, Columbia Emily Tull, Pikeville Daniella DeCruydt, Lawrence Tech Lara Kurt, SCAD-Savannah |
Second Team All-American Caleb Tate, Spring Arbor Eli Mayberry, Pikeville Andrew McWhorter, Campbellsville Tyler Seeley, Hastings Jacob Watts, Tennessee Wesleyan |
|
| Honorable Mention All-American Hannah Vaughn, Mount Vernon Nazarene Kiara Abanto, Cumberlands Ana Olaya, SCAD-Savannah Jasmine Saunders, Culver-Stockton Nicole Norris, Madonna |
Honorable Mention All-American Michael Harmon, Indiana Tech Tyrell Ingalls, SCAD-Savannah Tyler Betz, Tennessee Southern Korey Reichard, Concordia Jervon Webster, Lawrence Tech |
|
| 2021-2022 Women | 2021-2022 Men | |
| First Team All-American Maryssa Carey, Indiana Tech (POY) Caitlin Lucas, Baker Lauren Prebelich, Lawrence Tech Kristina Catoe, Pikeville Victoria Giardina, Lawrence Tech Serenity Quintero, St. Francis-Ill. |
First Team All-American Hayden Stippich, Tennessee Southern (POY) Tyrell Ingalls, SCAD-Savannah Zachary Price, Tennessee Wesleyan Marcus McClain, Indiana Tech Jordan Shepherd, Marian-Ind. James Bennett, Indiana Tech |
|
| Second Team All-American Tandess O'Neal, Marian-Ind Morgan Nunn, Indiana Tech Hannah Triske, Midland Bailey Gipson, Lawrence Tech Megan Allensworth, St. Francis-Ill. Amber Elliott, Huntington |
Second Team All-American Isaac Skalak, Peru State Caleb Marshall, Midway Caleb Tate, Spring Arbor Noah Campbell, Madonna Taylor Miller, Kansas Wesleyan Julian Salinas, SCAD-Savannah |
|
| 2020-2021 Women | 2020-2021 Men | |
| All-Americans Kristina Catoe, Pikeville (POY) Lindsay Brown, Martin Methodist Victoria Giardina, Lawrence Tech Megan Carpenter, Baker Makayla Lancioni, Concordia Jenna Beatty, Lourdes Brianna Logsdon, Union Hanna Duver, Grand View Chloe Long, Shawnee State Maryssa Carey, Indiana Tech Bailey Gipson, Lawrence Tech Ashley Moch, Campbellsville |
All-Americans Jeffery Mann, Marian-Ind. (POY) Nicholas Graveel, Marian-Ind. Marcus McClain, Indiana Tech Michael Weber, Lawrence Tech Jared Freed, Ottawa Aleksander Kostric, William Penn Jordan Shepard, Marian-Ind. Korey Reichard, Concordia Jacob Toelke, Thomas More Briton Helton, Tennessee Wesleyan Hayden Stippich, Martin Methodist Jacob Balser, Indiana Tech |
|
| 2019-2020 Women | 2019-2020 Men | |
| First Team All-American Lauren Piotrowski, Pikeville (POY) Maryssa Carey, Indiana Tech Rebekah Commane, SCAD-Savannah Pamela Perez Millan, SCAD-Savannah Abby Ragsdale, St. Francis-Ill. |
First Team All-American Benjamin Martinez, SCAD-Savannah (POY) Brady Adler, Martin Methodist Dylan Byars, SCAD-Savannah Dawson Maier, Indiana Tech Zach Mitchell, Grand View |
|
| Second Team All-American Lindsay Brown, Martin Methodist Megan Carpenter, Baker Brittney Schnicke, Midland Jordyn Stewart, Lourdes Jessica Wolfe, Pikeville |
Second Team All-American Jacob Balser, Indiana Tech Alex Glinski, SCAD-Savannah Brandon Magennis, Martin Methodist Thomas McNeal, Cumberlands Jalen Mosely, Midland |
|
| 2018-2019 Women | 2018-2019 Men | |
| First Team All-American Abigail Ragsdale, St. Francis-Ill. (POY) Maryssa Carey, Indiana Tech Mallory Liversedge, Pikeville Lauren Piotrowski, Pikeville Jessica Wolfe, Pikeville |
First Team All-American Sam Cantrell, Grand View (POY) Robert Kicmal, St. Francis-Ill. Curtis Majka, William Penn Zach Mitchell, Grand View Nick Walker, William Penn |
|
| Second Team All-American Rebekah Commane, SCAD-Savannah Cassidy Courey, Mount Mercy Sarah Doyle, Cumberlands Samantha Laird, Hastings Brittney Schnicke, Midland Brittney Turcotte, Pikeville |
Second Team All-American Blake Earnest, Hastings Alex Hoffman, Pikeville Zach Karr, Midland Chase Kaufman, Lawrence Tech Adam Morse, Grand View Maxwell Roers, Mount Mercy |
|
| 2017-2018 Women | 2017-2018 Men | |
| First Team All-American Caitlyn Johnson, Webber Int. (POY) Maryssa Carey, Indiana Tech Natalie Koprowitz, St. Ambrose Crystal Land, Campbellsville Nicole Troha, St. Francis-Ill. |
First Team All-American Michael Davidson, Calumet (POY) Sam Cantrell, Grand View Alex Glinski, SCAD-Savannah Evan Baranecky, Webber Int. Alex Ouellette, Concordia |
|
| Second Team All-American Kayla Crawford, St. Ambrose Jenna Coldiron, Pikeville Makayla Ericksen, Grand View Jessica Wolfe, Pikeville Rachel Barber, Ottawa |
Second Team All-American Tyler James, Calumet Michael Martell, Robert Morris-Ill. Matthew Cleary, Pikeville Michael Kicmal, St. Francis-Ill. Cory Hersha, Indiana Tech |
|
| 2016-2017 Women | 2016-2017 Men | |
| First Team All-American Rebecca Broerman, Grand View (POY) Kayla Crawford, St. Ambrose Caitlyn Johnson, Webber Int. Katie Maher, St. Ambrose Jenna Coldiron, Pikeville |
First Team All-American Nick Pate, Midland (POY) Andrew Letscher, Pikeville Giorgio Clinaz, Webber Int. David Lance, Webber Int. Nicco Vicari, Calumet |
|
| Second Team All-American Anna Andersson, Webber Int. Abigail Ragsdale, St. Francis-Ill. Tania Yusaf, Webber Int. Karlee Evans, Pikeville Taylor Bulthuis, Webber Int. |
Second Team All-American Zach Karr, Midland Jeffrey Holden, Calumet Zachary Hazel, Concordia Michael Davidson, Calumet Bryan Bourget, Robert Morris-Ill. |
|
| 2015-16 Women | 2015-16 Men | |
| First Team All-American Brittany Smith, Grand View (POY) Verity Crawley, Webber Int. Katie Maher, St. Ambrose Katelyn Simpson, Pikeville Emily Eckhoff, Hastings |
First Team All-American Michael Davidson, Calumet (POY) Ramon Hilferink, Webber Int. Matt Kuba, Calumet Zachary Fylling, Pikeville Ryan Zagar, Robert Morris-Ill. |
|
| Second Team All-American Shelby Fromm, Pikeville Shelby New, Huntington Taylor Davis, Marian Nicole Troha, St. Francis-Ill. Stephanie Adams, William Penn |
Second Team All-American Justin Dunn, Webber Int. Tylor Greene, Robert Morris-Ill. Joseph Bowers, Calumet Matt Sanders, Marian Nick Pate, Midland |
|
| 2014-15 Women | 2014-15 Men | |
| First Team All-American Sabrena Divis, Midland (POY) Kamilah Dammers, Webber Int. Brianna Larson, Pikeville Katelyn Simpson, Pikeville Brittany Smith, Grand View |
First Team All-American Nick Pate, Midland (POY) Justin Dunn, Webber Int. Ramon Hilferink, Webber Int. Matt Kuba, Calumet Ryan Zagar, R. Morris-Ill. |
|
| Second Team All-American Stephanie Cieslewicz, R. Morris-Ill. Shelby Fromm, Pikeville Caitlin Hoffman, St. Francis Shelby New, Huntington Fallon Tallman, Pikeville |
Second Team All-American Zachary Fylling, Pikeville Tylor Greene, R. Morris-Ill. Mitchell Katic, Calumet Matt Sanders, Marian Cameron Weier, R. Morris-Ill. |
|
| 2013-14 Women | 2013-14 Men | |
| First Team All-American Diana Zavjalova, Webber Int. (POY) Sabrena Divis, Midland Brittany Smith, Grand View Kamilah Dammers, Webber Int. Samantha Kelly, R. Morris-Ill. |
First Team All-American Perry Crowell, Midland (POY) Marshall Kent, R. Morris-Ill. Cameron Weier, R. Morris-Ill. Kristis Sergejevas, Webber Int. Andrew Anderson, Davenport |
|
| Second Team All-American Katelyn Simpson, Pikeville Lori Hanken, R. Morris-Ill. Emily Eckhoff, Hastings Verity Crawley, Webber Int. Andreya Teuber, Davenport |
Second Team All-American Matt Gasn, R. Morris-Ill. Justin Dunn, Webber Int. Cameron Foster, R. Morris-Ill. Ryan Zagar, R. Morris-Ill. Joe Gourneau, Midland |
|
| 2012-13 Women | 2012-13 Men | |
| First Team All-American Katie Thornton, Webber Int. (POY) Diana Zavjalova, Webbert Int. Christina Halen, Pikeville Caitlin Hoffman, R. Morris-Ill. Sabrena Divis, Midland |
First Team All-American Marshall Kent, R. Morris-Ill. (POY) Kyle King, R. Morris-Ill. Cameron Weier, R. Morris-Ill. Brandon Hott, Webber Int. Cameron Foster, William Penn |
|
| Second Team All-American Caitlin Campbell, Baker Katelyn Simpson, Pikeville Tawni Vollmer, R. Morris-Ill. Kamilah Dammers, Webber Int. Courtney Couch, Midland |
Second Team All-American Jacob Kent, R. Morris-Ill. Matt Gasn, R. Morris-Ill. Colin Champion, Webber Int. Perry Crowell, Midland Mike Wedemeier, Missouri Baptist |
|
| 2011-12 Women | 2011-12 Men | |
| First Team All-American Kim Yioulos, Pikeville (POY) Brandy Hensley, Pikeville Caitlin Hoffman, R. Morris-Ill. Kayla Rhoades, Marian Diana Zavjalova, Webber Int. |
First Team All-American Marshall Kent, R. Morris-Ill. (POY) Cameron Weier, R. Morris-Ill. Toby Kraus, Calumet Sean Rangel, William Penn Javier Diaz, Webber Int. |
|
| Second Team All-American Katie Sexton, R. Morris-Ill. Alejandra Mora, R. Morris-Ill. Katie Thornton, Webber Int. Brianne Underwood, William Penn Katie Maher, Midland |
Second Team All-American Jacob Kent, R. Morris-Ill. Dominic Partipilo, R. Morris-Ill. Perry Crowell, Midland Mitchell Katic, Calumet Kristis Sergejevos, Webber Int. |
|
| 2010-11 Women | 2010-11 Men | |
| First Team All-American Kim Yioulos, Pikeville (POY) Amanda Greene, Lindenwood Brandi Branka, McKendree Heather D'Errico, R.Morris-Ill. Jessica Santiago, Webber Int. |
First Team All-American Marcelo Suartz, Webber Int. (POY) Dean Richards, Lindenwood Chris Bardol, R.Morris-Ill. RJ Klann, Lindenwood Sammy Krucek, Calumet |
|
| Second Team All-American Diana Zavjalova, Webber Int. Jenny Petzoldt, Lindenwood Samantha Kelly, R.Morris-Ill. Amber Sells, NW Ohio Kristen Ruzicka, Midland |
Second Team All-American Javier Diaz, Webber Int. Jon Trzcinski, Webber Int. Frank Testa, Notre Dame - OH Sean Rangel, William Penn Mikey Hill, R.Morris-Illinois |
Gordon Teigen Service Award | Rookie of the Year | Kerm Helmer and Gordon Vadakin Coach of the Year
NCBCA All Americans | IBMA Collegiate Bowler of the Year Awards
NAIA All Americans | NTCA Awards